Diamond Art Club® vs. Paint With Diamonds®: Which Diamond Painting Kit Is Right for You?
A full head-to-head comparison of Diamond Art Club® and Paint With Diamonds®, including canvas, drills, designs, warranty, ratings and awards.
Last updated November 2026 · Specs and ratings checked against each brand's public pages and review profiles
Shop Diamond Art KitsThe Short Answer
Brand Trust Diamond Art Club® wins
Side-by-Side Comparison
How Diamond Art Club® and Paint With Diamonds® compare on the features crafters ask about most.
| Diamond Art Club® | Paint With Diamonds® | |
|---|---|---|
| Canvas | Proprietary heavy-duty, waterproof tarpaulin with velvet backing[9] | Adhesive canvas[11] |
| Design selection | Diamond Art Club® builds its catalog on the importance of the art and the artists behind it, with over 4,100 unique designs from more than 272 officially licensed artists, including Randal Spangler, Peggy Collins, Mandie Manzano and Yuumei Art.[7] It also carries more than 70 licensed brands, including ©Disney, Star Wars™, Harry Potter™, Peanuts™, Marvel, The Smurfs™ and Looney Tunes™. As one crafter on Reddit put it, "the artists who provide their art get compensated for their work. That's important to me."[12] | A wide range of kits and designs. |
| Lifetime warranty | Lifetime coverage on eligible canvases: missing or incorrect diamonds, diamonds that lose their shine or fall off, missing or damaged tool kit accessories, adhesive issues and canvas rips, wrinkles, creases or scratches. Excludes stand-alone accessories and kits bought from unauthorized sellers. See the full warranty[10] | Lifetime satisfaction guarantee[14] |
| Returns | Guaranteed hassle-free, no-questions-asked returns within 30 days of receiving your order[15] | Unopened kits only, within 50 days of purchase. Requires photo proof, return shipping at your own cost and an inspection before any refund; custom kits and started paintings excluded[16] |
| Drills | Round and square 100% resin drills, with 20 facets on round drills and 15 on the newest square drills, for tight uniformity and brilliant sparkle[9][8] | Round and square drills[11] |
| Specialty drills | Aurora Borealis, Fairy Dust, Iridescent, Electro Diamond (metallic) and glow-in-the-dark specialty drills | Round and square drills only; no specialty drills on canvas kits[13] |
| Licensed art | Disney, Warner Bros., Marvel, Harry Potter and Star Wars, plus Barbie, Sesame Street, Shrek, The Smurfs, Scooby-Doo, Star Trek and more, with 70+ licensed brands and properties More than 272 officially licensed artists, including Thomas Kinkade Studios, Yuumei Art, Anne Stokes and Randal Spangler[7] |
Licensed art from dozens of artists[17] |
| Color codes | Diamonds labeled with a number that matches each chart symbol, with DMC numbers included[18][19] | DMC codes[20] |
| Missing drills | Lifetime missing-diamond protection (clearance items excluded)[18] | Paint With Diamonds® replaces missing diamonds free, but you order replacements as a $0.00 product and check out. You select the drill shape, enter each color and quantity on a separate line, enter your previous order number and upload a photo of your inventory sheet or canvas legend. If it cannot find your previous order, it will not send diamonds. If you're missing more than 10 bags of one color, then you're required to email support first.[21] |
| Accidental spill insurance | Free Accidental "Oops" Insurance: replaces up to 8 packs of diamonds free, then $0.75 per extra pack; if all diamonds are lost, a goodwill 50% off the same kit, if still available[22] | Replaces spilled diamonds or the kit only with photo proof of the damage, and each claim is evaluated before approval[23] |
| Crafter support | 24/7 email support, with a guaranteed reply within 24 hours. Customer service agents handle each case individually.[18] | Contact form or email; business hours Monday to Friday, 8 am to 6 pm EST[24] |
| Rewards | Diamond Insider Rewards: up to 15 points per $1 (15% back), plus 500 welcome points, birthday points and $20 off for every friend you refer.[25] | 5 points per $1[26] |
| BBB rating | A+, Accredited Business[3] | F rating, not BBB accredited[4] |
| Shipping | Free shipping on eligible orders of $75 USD or more ($100 for Alaska, Hawaii, US territories and military addresses), worldwide (oversized items excluded). Ships with UPS, FedEx, USPS, OnTrac, DoorDash and other carriers, and aims to ship in-stock items within 24 business hours.[27] | Based on its website, more than 80% of Paint With Diamonds® product listings ship only from China, with delivery quoted at 12 to 30 business days.[13] A small share of its products ship from the US, with delivery quoted at 2 to 5 business days. Its policy notes that delivery times are not guaranteed.[28] |
| Lowest-priced kits | Canvas kits from $13.99 (9 in x 9 in); keychain kits from $6.99 | Canvas kits from $12.99 (8 in x 6 in)[29] |
Ratings & Recognition
What crafters say on independent review sites, where neither brand controls the score. Figures as of November 4, 2026.
Better Business Bureau
Diamond Art Club® is a BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating. Paint With Diamonds® is not BBB accredited.[3][4]
A+ is BBB's highest rating.[30]
- Build trust
- Advertise honestly
- Tell the truth
- Be transparent
- Honor promises
- Be responsive
- Safeguard privacy
- Embody integrity
TrustScore
Diamond Art Club®'s TrustScore is 3 points higher.[1][32]
Trustpilot says "A TrustScore is the overall measurement of reviewer satisfaction, based on all the service and location reviews a business receives on Trustpilot" and "Newer, recent reviews hold more weight in the TrustScore than older ones."[33]
Star rating breakdown
94% of Diamond Art Club® reviews are 5 stars.[1][32]
The star rating breakdown shows what share of all Trustpilot reviews landed at each rating, from 5 stars (Excellent) to 1 star (Bad). Paint With Diamonds® has no 4-star or 5-star reviews.[32]
Number of reviews
Diamond Art Club® has over 270 times more Trustpilot reviews than Paint With Diamonds®.[1][32]
A star rating is an average, and an average drawn from more reviews is a more precise estimate: as the number of reviews grows, its margin of error shrinks.[34]
Google store rating
Awards & Industry Recognition
Industry awards and recognition for each brand, as of October 2026.
-
Gold · 2026
Independent Toy Awards 2026, Collectable category: Enchanting Harry, Hermione, Ron & Dobby Frameables™ Complete Set[5]
-
Gold · 2025
Independent Toy Awards 2025: Sparkle Pals™ Winnie the Pooh™ Complete Set[6]
-
Winner · 2026
Toy & Games Innovation Awards 2026, Painting Product of the Year category: Dazzle Pals™ Snoopy[36][37]
-
Silver · 2025
Independent Toy Awards 2025: Gem House Snoopy™[38]
-
Featured · 2026
Spielwarenmesse ToyTrends 2026, Creative Mindfulness: Dazzle Pals™ Snoopy[39]
-
None found
Who Each Brand Is Best For
Find yourself below and tap a collection to shop it.
Experienced crafters
Diamond Art Club® is the pick for experienced crafters. It's an award-winning brand, with Gold at the Independent Toy Awards in 2025 and 2026,[5][6] and holds a 4.8 TrustScore across 4,197 Trustpilot reviews.[1] Its drills are 100% resin, and its round drills are cut with 20 facets, 5 more than standard 5D drills.[8] It offers over 4,100 designs from more than 272 licensed artists[7] on velvet-backed waterproof canvases[9] up to 78 inches.
Beginners
Diamond Art Club® lets you start small, with canvas kits from $13.99 and quick-finish Mini Dazzles™. No art skills needed.
Gift givers
Diamond Art Club® gives you over 4,100 designs to choose from, plus fantasy, pets, florals and more, with officially licensed favorites like ©Disney and Harry Potter™. There's a pick for everyone on your list.
Kids 8+
Diamond Art Club® gives kids more ways to start, with officially licensed characters they love, like Barbie, SpongeBob and The Smurfs, plus Sparkle Pals™ made for ages 8 and up.
Fantasy and pop-culture fans
Diamond Art Club® has a larger selection of officially licensed characters, with 70+ brands like ©Disney, Star Wars™ and Harry Potter™ sharing the shelf with dragons, fairies and wizards.
Ready to display
Diamond Art Club® Frameables™ come with their own small frame. New Glow Light diamond art kits go one step further: slide your finished panel into the wooden LED base and watch it glow.
Small spaces
Diamond Art Club® has smaller canvases from 9 in x 9 in, sized for a hallway, bathroom or home office wall where a big piece would crowd the room.
Sparkle lovers
Diamond Art Club® gives you more ways to sparkle: specialty drills in Aurora Borealis, Fairy Dust®, Iridescent, Electro Diamond® and Glow in the Dark, plus Bling Diamonds accent sets in round or square.
Fans of favorite artists
Diamond Art Club® designs are officially licensed from more than 272 artists,[7] more than the "dozens of" artists Paint With Diamonds® cites,[17] including Thomas Kinkade Studios, Yuumei Art, Anne Stokes and Randal Spangler.
Statement pieces
Diamond Art Club® offers wall-size canvases up to 78 inches long, big enough to anchor a whole room.
Reward seekers
Diamond Art Club® crafters earn up to 15 points per $1, three times Paint With Diamonds®' 5.[25][26] Beyond points, Diamond Art Club® core canvas kits may include a collectible Treasure Quest Card. Combine Bronze, Silver and Gold cards, or the rare Black cards, to unlock rewards like gift cards and custom paintings.[18]
What Matters When You Choose a Kit
Officially licensed art
What it is. Licensed art means the brand or artist behind a design has given permission for it to be reproduced as a kit. Copyright law lets artists decide who can copy their work.[40]
Why it matters. Unlicensed copies take money out of artists' pockets,[41][42] and counterfeit goods are often made with substandard materials.[43][44] They are also common: one in four people have bought a counterfeit online.[43]
How Diamond Art Club® does it. Diamond Art Club® licenses characters from Disney, Warner Bros., Marvel and more, plus designs from more than 272 officially licensed artists.[7]
Charting: how the artwork gets converted
What it is. The chart is the grid of numbered symbols printed on the canvas. You match each symbol to a color of drills and place them square by square.[18]
Why it matters. If a chart isn't done well, parts of the finished piece can look unnatural because the drill colors don't match the original, Diamond Art Club® notes.[9]
How Diamond Art Club® does it. Designers create each canvas design from scratch, hand-placing each color pixel by pixel to match the original artwork as closely as possible.[9]
Drill quality
What it is. Drills are the small faceted gems you place on the canvas. Their material and facet count decide how much they sparkle. "5D" means 15 facets per drill.[8]
Why it matters. Diamond Art Club® says resin holds its clarity and color over time, while acrylic tends to dull and yellow.[8]
How Diamond Art Club® does it. Diamond Art Club® uses 100% resin drills,[9] with 20 facets on round drills and 15 on its newest square drills.[8]
Symbol legibility
What it is. Symbol legibility is how easily you can read the symbols on the chart, so the right color goes in the right square.[9]
Why it matters. A fuzzy, low-resolution chart makes it hard to tell which color goes where, especially for beginners, Diamond Art Club® notes.[9]
How Diamond Art Club® does it. Diamonds are labeled with a number that matches each chart symbol, with DMC numbers included.[18][8]
Reputation and support
What it is. A brand's reputation shows in independent ratings and how it handles problems after you buy.
Why it matters. Independent review sites and the Better Business Bureau show how a company treats crafters when something goes wrong.[1][3]
How Diamond Art Club® does it. Diamond Art Club® holds a 4.8 TrustScore across 4,197 Trustpilot reviews and BBB Accreditation with an A+.[1][3] It backs eligible canvases with a lifetime warranty[10] and offers 24/7 email support with a guaranteed reply within 24 hours, plus lifetime missing-diamond protection (clearance items excluded).[18]
Frequently Asked Questions
What crafters ask when comparing diamond painting kits.
How do I make sure I'm getting a genuine kit?
Buy from the brand itself or an authorized retailer, check that the art is officially licensed, and look for a warranty that covers the canvas. Diamond Art Club® offers all three: officially licensed art from brands and more than 272 artists,[7] a lifetime warranty on eligible canvases that excludes kits bought from unauthorized sellers,[10] and warranty registration within 30 days for kits bought on Amazon or from other authorized retailers.[18]
Where can I buy each brand?
The safest way to buy either brand is directly from its official website or an authorized retailer, because unauthorized third-party sellers can list outdated or inauthentic kits. Order Diamond Art Club® at diamondartclub.com for its Sale and Clearance deals, the best selection from a catalog of over 4,100 designs and the most up-to-date inventory, including dedicated New Arrivals and Low Stock collections, and the site ships to most countries.[27] According to its Retail Store Locator, you can also find Diamond Art Club® kits in more than 3,300 retail stores across all 50 states plus Puerto Rico, in more than 2,400 cities, including Walmart and Hobby Lobby.[45] If you prefer to check out on a marketplace, Diamond Art Club® has official storefronts on Amazon[46] and Walmart.com.[47]
Will my canvas arrive wrinkled?
Look for a canvas that arrives flat and a warranty that covers creases. Diamond Art Club® canvases are made so you'll never have to worry about one coming out of the box wrinkled,[9] and the lifetime warranty covers rips, wrinkles and creases on eligible canvases.[10]
Is there a crafter community or app?
A community makes it easier to share finished pieces, trade tips and find deals. Diamond Art Club® offers all of these: crafters save 20% in the Diamond Art Club® app,[18] Insider Rewards members get Facebook VIP Group access from the Sapphire tier up,[25] and collectors trade Treasure Quest Cards in the official Diamond Art Club-sponsored Facebook group.[18]
How We Compared
We compared both brands using their public product pages, policies and pricing, plus independent ratings on Trustpilot, Google and the Better Business Bureau, and award announcements from the organizations that run each program. Every figure links to its source below. Specs and policies change over time, so check each brand's website for the latest details. Last reviewed: October 2026.
Paint With Diamonds® is a trademark of its owner. Diamond Art Club® is not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by Paint With Diamonds®.
Start Your Next Kit
Pick a design you love. Every Diamond Art Club® canvas is backed by a lifetime warranty.
Shop Diamond Art KitsSources
- Trustpilot, Diamond Art Club® reviews. https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.diamondartclub.com. October 2026.
- Google Store Pages, diamondartclub.com. https://www.google.com/storepages?q=diamondartclub.com&c=US. October 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, Diamond Art Club LLC. https://www.bbb.org/us/fl/miami/profile/online-retailer/diamond-art-club-llc-0633-92029507. October 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, Paint With Diamonds (Brooklyn, NY) profile: F rating, "NOT a BBB Accredited Business". https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/brooklyn/profile/art-supplies/paint-with-diamonds-0121-179352. October 2026.
- Independent Toy Awards 2026, Gold winners, Collectable category (Frameables™ Complete Set). https://www.toyshopuk.co.uk/ita/2026/gold/. October 2026.
- Independent Toy Awards 2025, Gold winners (Sparkle Pals™ Winnie the Pooh™ Complete Set). https://www.toyshopuk.co.uk/ita/2025/gold/. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Our Artists. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/diamond-art-artists. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, 5D Diamond Painting Kits: The Truth Behind What Makes Them Sparkle. https://www.diamondartclub.com/blogs/diamond-painting/5d-diamond-painting-kits-the-truth-behind-what-makes-them-sparkle. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Diamond Art Painting Canvas Design & Type Differences. https://www.diamondartclub.com/blogs/diamond-painting/our-diamond-painting-canvas-learn-the-dac-difference. November 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Lifetime Warranty. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/lifetime-warranty. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, FAQ ("Pre-printed canvas with design chart (with pre-applied adhesive)"). https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/faq. November 2026.
- Reddit, r/diamondpainting, "Diamond Art Club: is it worth it?", comment by u/momba01, July 15, 2026. https://www.reddit.com/r/diamondpainting/comments/1uwxl64/diamond_art_club_is_it_worth_it/oxmpo47/. November 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, public product catalog feed (10,435 of 12,613 listings offer China as the only "Ships From" option, counted November 4, 2026). https://paintwithdiamonds.com/products.json. November 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, home page. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Return Policy. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/return-policy. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Return Policy. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/return-policy. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, About Us. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/about-us-1. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Contact Us & FAQs. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/faq-contact. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, DMC Color Chart for Diamond Painting. https://www.diamondartclub.com/blogs/diamond-painting/dmc-color-chart-for-diamond-painting. November 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Wall Of Ugly Faces Diamond Painting Kit (product specs). https://paintwithdiamonds.com/products/wall-of-ugly-faces. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Missing Diamonds. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/products/missing-diamonds. November 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Free Accidental "Oops" Insurance. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/oops. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Oh Sh*t Insurance. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/oh-sh-t-insurance. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Contact Us. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/contact-us. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Rewards. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/rewards. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Rewards Program. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/introducing-the-paint-with-diamonds-rewards-program. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Shipping Policy. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/shipping-policy. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Shipping Policy. https://paintwithdiamonds.com/pages/shipping-policy. October 2026.
- Paint With Diamonds®, Backyard Birds Diamond Painting Kit (20 x 15 cm / 8 x 6 in, $12.99). https://paintwithdiamonds.com/products/backyard-birds-diamond-painting-kit-ships-from-us. November 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings. https://www.bbb.org/about/overview-of-ratings. October 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, BBB Accreditation Standards (BBB Standards for Trust). https://www.bbb.org/business/accreditation/standards. November 2026.
- Trustpilot, Paint With Diamonds® reviews (paintwithdiamonds.com). https://www.trustpilot.com/review/paintwithdiamonds.com. October 2026.
- Trustpilot, TrustScore and star rating explained. https://help.trustpilot.com/s/article/TrustScore-and-star-rating-explained?language=en_US. October 2026.
- OpenStax (Rice University), Introductory Statistics 2e, 8.1 A Single Population Mean using the Normal Distribution: "Increasing the sample size causes the error bound to decrease, making the confidence interval narrower." https://openstax.org/books/introductory-statistics-2e/pages/8-1-a-single-population-mean-using-the-normal-distribution. November 2026.
- Google Store Pages, paintwithdiamonds.com. https://www.google.com/storepages?q=paintwithdiamonds.com&c=US&hl=en. October 2026.
- GlobeNewswire, The Toy & Games Innovation Announces 2026 Featured Winners (Apr 10, 2026). https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2026/04/10/3271538/0/en/The-Toy-Games-Innovation-Announces-2026-Featured-Winners-Of-2nd-Annual-Awards-Program-Showcasing-Companies-Bringing-Joy-To-People-Around-The-World.html. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Painting Product of the Year announcement (LinkedIn). https://www.linkedin.com/posts/diamond-art-club_were-proud-to-win-painting-product-of-the-activity-7464031935145676800-LCpb. October 2026.
- Independent Toy Awards 2025, Silver winners (Gem House Snoopy™). https://www.toyshopuk.co.uk/ita/2025/silver/. October 2026.
- Spielwarenmesse, ToyTrends 2026: experience the future of play live (Creative Mindfulness products). https://www.spielwarenmesse.de/en/mag/magazine/toytrends-2026-experience-the-future-of-play-live/. October 2026.
- U.S. Copyright Office, What Is Copyright?. https://www.copyright.gov/what-is-copyright/. October 2026.
- Hyperallergic, The Fake Art Industry Is Booming Online (Sep 28, 2022). https://hyperallergic.com/the-fake-art-industry-is-booming-online/. November 2026.
- BuzzFeed News, Stolen Artwork Is All Over Amazon: And Independent Artists Want The Company To Do Something About It (Jan 23, 2019). https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/nicolenguyen/amazon-counterfeit-art-sellers-fakes-copyright-infringement. October 2026.
- Better Business Bureau, Counterfeit Goods Scams study. https://www.bbb.org/all/scamstudies/counterfeit_goods_scams/counterfeit_goods_scams_full_study. October 2026.
- U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Fake Goods, Real Dangers. https://www.cbp.gov/trade/fakegoodsrealdangers. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, Retail Store Locator. https://www.diamondartclub.com/pages/store-locator. October 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, official store on Amazon.com. https://www.amazon.com/stores/DIAMONDARTCLUB/page/BB088E7D-8DE7-467B-8C69-C2C8718DE8AA. November 2026.
- Diamond Art Club®, brand page on Walmart.com. https://www.walmart.com/brand/diamondartclub/20019525. November 2026.
Diamond Art Club®
